CHEMICAL WEAPONS IN THE BALTIC SEA: POTENTIAL THREATS TO THE ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC HEALTH; COMPLETED AND UPCOMING TASKS ON THE WAY TO SOLVING THE PROBLEM

Authors

  • V. T. Paka Shirshov Institute of Oceanology, Russian Academy of Sciences
  • V. N. Nabatov Shirshov Institute of Oceanology, Russian Academy of Sciences

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.29006/1564-2291.JOR-2022.50(2).7

Keywords:

Baltic Sea, chemical weapons dumpsites, environmental threats

Abstract

A brief overview of potential threats from chemical weapons (CW) dumped in the Baltic Sea is presented. The most common, long-acting and dangerous chemical warfare agents (CWAs) are those that are persistent in the marine environment. The main mechanisms of the transfer of CWAs from dumpsites to other areas of the Baltic Sea are considered. It is noted that the risk of acute effects on biota and humans of CWAs migrating in the form of polluted particulate suspended matter and polluting the sea bottom at large distances from dumpsites is negligible, but with regard to the harmfulness of CWAs entering the food chain, additional studies of their mutagenic and carcinogenic effects are needed. A step-by-step path for the development of complex research on the problem, the tasks of the stages and the role of international cooperation in their solution are presented. The need to continue field studies is substantiated to complete the mapping of dumped CW and monitoring areas of secondary contamination of the seabed, while attention should be paid to the identification of potentially hazardous underwater objects based on a complete chemical analysis of samples taken near the discovered artefacts. If it is impossible to cooperate with Western partners, Russia must find its own forces and means to complete the research in full.

References


  1. Baršienė, J., L. Butrimaviciene, W. Grygiel, V. Stunzėnas, R. Valskienė, and J. Greiciu­naite, 2016: Environmental genotoxicity assessment along the transport routes of chemical munitions leading to the dumping areas in the Baltic. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 103, 45–53.

  2. Bełdowski, J., Z. Klusek, M. Szubska, R. Turja, A. I. Bulczak, D. Rak, M. Brenner, T. Lang, L. Kotwicki, K. Grzelak, J. Jakacki, N. Fricke, A. Östin, U. Olsson, J. Fabisiak, G. Garnaga, J. R. Nyholm, P. Majewski, K. Broeg, M. Söderström, P. Vanninen, S. Popiel, J. Nawała, K. Lehtonen, R. Berglind, and B. Schmidt, 2016: Chemical munitions search and assessment –an evaluation of the dumped munitions problem in the Baltic Sea. Deep Sea Research. Part II: Topical studies in oceanography, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr2.2015.01.017.

  3. Bełdowski, J., J. Jakacki, M. Grabowski, T. Lang, K. Weber, L. Kotwicki, V. Paka, D. Rak, M. Golenko, M. Czub, and M. Söderström, 2018: Best practices in monitoring. Towards the monitoring of dumped munitions threat (MODUM): A study of chemical munitions dumpsites in the Baltic Sea. Dordrecht, Springer Netherlands, 213–239.

  4. Bełdowski, J., M. Brenner, and K. Lehtonen, 2020: Contaminated by war: A brief history of Sea-dumping of munitions. Marine Environmental Research, 162, 105–189.

  5. Bełdowski, J., M. Czub, M. Söderström, T. Frey, M. Brenner, A. Vanninen, J. Wendt, S. Popiel, J. Fabisiak, J. Jakacki, M. Grabowski, K. Weber, M. Reuter, A. Tomes, V. Paka, M. Golenko, G. Dawson, and E. Maser, in press: The environmental impact of Sea-dumped chemical munitions and the need for remediation efforts. NATURE.

  6. Bochkov, N. P., 2003: Ekologicheskaya genetika cheloveka (Human ecological genetics). Ekologicheskaya genetika, 1 (1), 16–21.

  7. Carton, G. and A. Jagusiewicz, 2009: Historic Disposal of Munitions in US and European Coastal Waters, How Historic Information Can be Used in Characterizing and Managing Risk. Mar. Technol. Soc. J., 43, 16–32.

  8. CHEMSEA, 2013: CHEMSEA findings. Results from the CHEMSEA project – chemical munitions Search and assessment, CHEMSEA consortium: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324149647_CHEMSEA_Findings-Results_from_the_CHEMSEA_project_chemical_munitions_search_and_assessment, (last accessed 10.06.2022).

  9. Chmielińska, K., D. Hubé, T. Bausinger, S. Simon, G. Rivière, P. Fauser, and H. Sanderson, 2019: Environmental contamination with persistent cyclic mustard gas impurities and transformation products. Global Security Health Science and Policy, 4 (1), 14–23.

  10. Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction. 1992, Geneva.

  11. Czub, J., J. Nawała, S. Popiel, T. Brzezinski, P. Maszczyk, H. Sanderson, E. Maser, D. Gordon, D. Dziedzic, B. Dawidziuk, J. Pijanowska, J. Fabisiak, M. Szubska, T. Lang, V. Vanninen, H. Niemikoski, T. Missiaen, K. Lehtonen, J. Bełdowski, and L. Kotwicki, 2021: Acute aquatic toxicity of arsenic-based chemical warfare agents to Daphnia magna. Aquatic Toxicology, 230, 1–11.

  12. Emelyanov, A. S., A. A. Konev, E. O. Vershilova, and D. S. Fyodorov, 2010: Protein complex of Drosophila ATRX/XNP and HP1a is required for the formation of pericentric beta-heterochromatin in vivo. Journal of Biological Chemistry, 285 (20), 15027–15037.

  13. Greenberg, M., K. Sexton, and D. Vearrier, 2016: Sea-dumped chemical weapons: environmental risk, occupational hazard. Clinical Toxicology, 54, 79–91.

  14. HELCOM, 1994: Report on chemical munitions dumped in the Baltic Sea. Report to the 16th мeeting of Helsinki Commission, 8–11 March 1994, from the ad hoc working group on dumped chemical munition (HELCOM CHEMU). Copenhagen, Danish environmental protection agency.

  15. HELCOM, 1995: Final report of the ad hoc working group on dumped chemical munition (HELCOM CHEMU) to the 16th meeting of the Helsinki Commission. HELCOM.

  16. HELCOM, 2013: Chemical munitions dumped in the Baltic Sea, 3 October, 2013. Report of the ad hoc expert group to update and review the existing information on dumped chemical munitions in the Baltic Sea (HELCOM MUNI). HELCOM.

  17. Hoher, N., R. Turja, M. Brenner, J. Nyholm, A. Ostin, P. Leffler, L. Butrimaviciene, J. Barsiene, M. Halme, M. Karjalainen, H. Niemikoski, P. Vanninen, K. Broeg, K. Lehtonen, and R. Berglind, 2019: Toxic effects of chemical warfare agent mixtures on the mussel Mytilus trossulus in the Baltic Sea: A laboratory exposure study. Marine Environmental Research, 145, 112–122.

  18. Jakacki, J., J. Andrzejewski, A. Przyborska, M. Muzyka, D. Gordon, J. Nawala, S. Popiel, M. Golenko, V. Zhurbas, and V. Paka, 2020: High resolution model for assessment of contamination by chemical warfare agents dumped in the Baltic Sea. Marine Environmental Research, 161, 105–122.

  19. Kalinowski, R., E. Chrzanowska, and M. Brytan, 2013: Czy istniejące standardy jakości środowiska dla wybranych fosforoorganicznych bojowych środków trujących zapewniają również ochronę ekosystemów? Ochrona Środowiska i Zasobów Naturalnych, 24, 39–41.

  20. Katkova, M. N., 2009: Otsenka dermalnogo riska dlja naselenia prozhivajushego v rajone dampinga hemitcheskogo oruzhia v Baltijskom more (Dermal risk assessment for population at the area of chemical weapons damping in the Baltic Sea). Theoretical and applied ecology, 4, 50–55.

  21. Kharchenko, T. V., L. G. Arzhavkina, S. P. Los, A. V. Zhekalov, A. S. Kruchkova, and A. D. Sinjachkin, 2012: Genotoksicheskoe dejstvie toksikantov otnosjashihsja k himicheskomu oruzhiju i productov ich destructsii na somaticheskie kletki cheloveka (Genotoxic impact of toxicants from chemical weapons and their destruction products on human somatic cells). Newspaper of military-medical academy, 4, 266–269.

  22. Klusek, Z. and M. Grabowski, 2018: Results of Acoustic Research in the CM Deploying Areas. Towards the monitoring of dumped munitions threat (MODUM): A study of chemical munitions dumpsites in the Baltic Sea. Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht, 49–70.

  23. Lang, T., L. Kotwicki, M. Czub, K. Grzelak, L. Weirup, and K. Straumer, 2018: The health status of fish and benthos communities in hemical munitions dumpsites in the Baltic Sea. Towards the monitoring of dumped munitions threat (MODUM): A study of chemical munitions dumpsites in the Baltic Sea. Dordrecht, Springer Netherlands, 129–148.

  24. Lastumaki, A., R. Turja, M. Brenner, P. Vanninen, H. Niemikoski, L. Butrimaviciene, M. Stankevičiūtė, and K. Lehtonen, 2020: Biological effects of dumped chemical weapons in the Baltic Sea: A multi-biomarker study using caged mussels at the Bornholm main dumping site. Marine Environmental Research, 161, 38–51.

  25. Lehtonen K., S. Lenio, R. Schneider, and M. Leivuori, 2013: Assessment of the Baltic dumpsites. Presentation given at 4th periodic meeting of the CHEMSEA project. Hamburg.

  26. Li, C., R. K. Srivastava, and M. Athar, 2016: Biological and environmental hazards associated with exposure to chemical warfare agents: arsenicals. Annuals of NY Academy of Science, 1378 (1), 143–157.

  27. Matthäus, W., D. Nehring, R. Feistel, G. Nausch, U. Mohrholz, and H. Lass, 2006: The inflow of high saline water into the Baltic Sea. State and Evolution of the Baltic Sea, 1952–2005. Eds: R. Feistel, G. Nausch, and N. Wasmund (Hoboken, NJ: Wiley), 265–309.

  28. MERCW, 2006: Modelling of environmental risks related to Sea-dumped chemical weapons. http://cordis.europa.eu/project/rcn/74863_en.html, (last accessed 10.10.2021).

  29. MODUM, 2018: Towards the Monitoring of Dumped Munitions Threat: A Study of Chemical Munitions Dumpsites in the Baltic Sea. Eds: J. Bełdowski, R. Been, E. K. Turmus. Springer, NATO Science for Peace and Security Series, Sub-Series C. Environmental Security, 240 p.

  30. Medvedeva, N., J. Polyak, H. Kankaanpaa, and T. Zaytseva, 2009: Microbial responses to sulfur mustard dumped in the Baltic Sea. Marine Environmental Research, 68, 71–81.

  31. Missiaen, T. and P. Feller, 2008: Very-high-resolution seismic and magnetic investigations of a chemical munition dumpsite in the Baltic Sea. Journal of Applied Geophysics, 65 (3–4), 142–154.

  32. Missiaen, T., M. Söderström, I. Popescu, and P. Vanninen, 2010: Evaluation of a chemical munition dumpsite in the Baltic Sea based on geophysical and chemical investigations. Science of the Total Environment, 408, 3536–3553.

  33. National Report of the Russian Federation, 1993: Complex analysis of the hazard related to the captured German chemical weapons dumped in the Baltic Sea. Moscow.

  34. NATO/CCMS, 1995: Chemical contamination. Report No. 205. Cross-border environmental problems emanating from defence-related installations and activities. 2. Brussels.

  35. Niemikoski, H., K. Straumer, A. Ahvo, R. Turja., M. Brenner, T. Rautanen, T. Lang, K. Lehtonen, and P. Vanninen, 2020: Detection of chemical warfare agent related phenylarsenic compounds and multi-biomarker responses in cod (Gadus morhua) from munition dumpsites. Marine Environmental Research, 162, 105–129.

  36. Paka, V. T. and M. V. Spiridonov, 2002: Research of dumped chemical weapons made by R/V “Professor Shtokman” in the Gotland, Bornholm and Skagerrak dump sites. Missiaen & Henriet, Renard Centre of Marine Geology, Belgium, 27–42.

  37. Paka, V. T., 2004: Zatoplennoe himitcheskoe oruzhie: sostojanie problemy (Drowned chemical weapons: status of the problem). Russian chemical journal, XLVIII (4), 99–109.

  38. Paka, V. T. and N. N. Golenko, 2004: Resultaty eksperimentalnych issledovaniy “bolshogo Baltiyskogo zatoka” v 2003 godu (Field study of “the big Baltic inflow” in the year 2003). Complex investigations of processes, characteristics and resources of Russian seas in Nord-Western basin. Apatity, 367–387.

  39. Paka, V. T. and V. A. Chechko, 2018: Obsledovanie donnych otlozheniy vblizi podvodnych istochnikov zagrjazneniy (Survey of bottom deposits nearby of underwater sources of contamination). Oceanology, 8 (5), 803–808.

  40. Rahmanin, Y. A., 2005: Rol geneticheskih issledovanij pri otsenke vlijania faktorov okruzha­jushej sredy na zdorovje cheloveka (Role of genetic factors in influence of environmental fac­tors on human health). Hygiene and sanitation, 6, 59–62.

  41. Rukovodstvo po otsenke riska dlja zdorovja naselenia pri vozdeystvii chimitcheskih veshestv zagrjaznjajushih okrizhajushuju sredu (Manual for assessment of population health risk under effect of chemical substances polluting of environmrnt). Р 2.1.10.1920-04, 2004: Gossanepidnadzor of the Russian Health Ministry, 143.

  42. Sanderson, H., P. Fauser, M. Thomsen, and P. Sorensen, 2007: PBT screening profile of chemical warfare agents (CWAs). Journal of Hazard Mater, 148 (1–2), 210–215.

  43. Sanderson, H., P. Fauser, M. Thomsen, and P. Sorensen, 2008: Screening level fish community risk assessment of chemical warfare agents in the Baltic Sea. Journal of Hazard Mater, 154, 846–857.

  44. Sanderson, H., P. Fauser, M. Thomsen, and P. Sorensen, 2009: Human health risk screening due to consumption of fish contaminated with chemical warfare agents in the Baltic Sea. Journal of Hazard Mater, 162, 416–422.

  45. Sanderson, H., P. Fauser, M. Thomsen, P. Vanninen, M. Soderstrom, Y. Savin, I. Khalikov, A. Hirvonen, S. Niiranen, T. Missiaen, A. Gress, P. Borodin, N. Medvedeva, Y. Polyak, V. Paka, V. Zhurbas, and P. Feller, 2010: Environmental hazards of sea-dumped chemical weapons. Environmental Science and Technology, 44, 4389–4394.

  46. Sanderson, H., P. Fauser, M. Rahbek, and J. B. Larsen, 2014: Review of environmental exposure concentrations of chemical warfare agent residues and associated the fish community risk following the construction and completion of the Nord Stream gas pipeline between Russia and Germany. J. of Hazardous Materials, 279, 518–526.

  47. Söderström, M., A. Östin, J. Qvarnström, R. Magnusson, J. Rattfelt-Nyholm, M. Vaher, P. Jõul, H. Lees, M. Kaljurand, M. Szubska, P. Vanninen, and J. Bełdowski, 2018: Chemical analysis of dumped chemical warfare agents during the MODUM project. Towards the monitoring of dumped munitions threat (MODUM): A study of chemical munitions dumpsites in the Baltic Sea. Dordrecht, Springer Netherlands, 71–103.

  48. Stipa, T. and V. Paka, 2006: Modelling of ecological risks related to sea-dumped chemical weapons (MERCW). Proceedings of 2006 IEEE US/EU Baltic International Symposium, 583–586.

  49. Tarasov, V. A., 2009: Otsenka kantserogennoj activnosti himitcheskih soedinenij: problemy I perspectivy (Evaluation of carcinogenic activity for chemical compounds: problems and prospects). Proceedings of V Congress of Vavilov society of geneticists and breeders, Moscow, IOGen RAN, 71–76.

  50. Vanninen, P., A. Östin, J. Bełdowski, E. Pedersen, M. Söderström, M. Szubska, M. Grabowski, G. Siedlewicz, M. Czub, S. Popiel, J. Nawała, D. Dziedzic, J. Jakacki, and B. Pączek, 2020: Exposure status of sea-dumped chemical warfare agents in the Baltic Sea. Marine Environmental Research, 161, 1–10.

  51. Vesela, S., K. Kuca, and D. Jun, 2006: Toxicity of the nerve agent tabun to Daphnia magna, a new experimental species in military toxicology. Chemistry and Ecology, 22, 175–180.

  52. Wilkinson, I., R. Zilinskas, A. M. Steiger, D. Steiger, C. Ong, T. Chapman, B. Brodsky, J. Newman, and P. G. Brewer, 2017: Chemical weapon munitions dumped at sea: an interactive map. https://www.nonproliferation.org/chemical-weapon-munitions-dumped-at-sea/ (last accessed 03.07.2020).

  53. Zhurbas, V., J. Elken, and G. Vali, 2008: Pathways of suspended particles released in the bottom boundary layer of the Bornholm Deep, Baltic Sea (Numerical Simulations). Proceedings of Ieee/Oes Us/Eu-Baltic International Symposium, 61–65.

Downloads

Published

2022-08-29

Issue

Vol. 50 No. 2 (2022): Journal of Oceanological Research

Section

Marine geology, geophysics and geochemistry

License

Transfer of copyrights occurs on the basis of a license agreement between the Author and Shirshov Institute of Oceanology, RAS

Most read articles by the same author(s)